RSA Logo
Course Thumbnail
RON SMITH & ASSOCIATES, INC.
LPA17 - Exclusion and Inconclusive Decisions

Course Description

This course is dedicated to diving deep into exclusion and inconclusive decisions, with a structured focus around arriving at correct exclusion and inconclusive conclusions.  The course begins with a review of orientation as one of the most common reasons that examiners arrive at erroneous exclusion decisions.  We then learn about the evolution of exclusion decisions in the latent print industry, what makes exclusion decisions difficult, and evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of blanket rules on exclusions.  A lot of time is spent on exercises built to combat erroneous exclusion and erroneous inconclusive conclusions including an entire day dedicated to comparing and evaluating level three detail.  We also learn about forgeries and fabrications and how they can impact exclusion and inconclusive conclusions, including how to detect them in casework.  As additions, we spend time tracking ridges through distorted areas of latent prints.  We cover the one-discrepancy rule, and why that has changed, including images displaying one discrepancy that are clearly a correct association.  We also spend a lot of time reviewing single latent to single known images for inconclusive conclusions, and appropriate reasons for inconclusive decisions.

Course Objectives

At the completion of this course, the students should be able to:

  • Practically apply orientation clues to arrive at a correct up/down orientation of latent prints
  • Understand the history and evolution of a two-conclusion range including non-identification to a three-conclusion range including exclusion and inconclusive
  • Understand the various meaning of terms “negative,” “no identification,” “elimination,” and “exclusion
  • Understand the various proposed “blanket rules” to arrive at an exclusion decision and the strengths and weaknesses of these rules
  • Understand the strength of the conclusion that must apply in order to arrive at an exclusion decision
  • Practically be able to track ridges through portions of latent prints that display distortion
  • Practically be able to compare significantly more difficult latent prints
  • Understand latent print forgeries
  • Understand latent print fabrications
  • Understand the difference between latent print forgeries and fabrications
  • Understand clues to recognize latent print forgeries and fabrications
  • Understand the value of level 3 details
  • Practically be able to compare based on incipient ridges
  • Practically be able to compare based on pores
  • Practically be able to compare based on edges of ridges
  • Understand the history of the one-discrepancy rule, and why it has changed
  • Understand the terminology and definition of inconclusive conclusions
  • Understand the reasons why examiners may arrive at inconclusive conclusions
  • Understand what erroneous exclusions and erroneous exclusions are and why they occur
  • Be able to apply practical techniques to avoid erroneous exclusion conclusions
  • Be able to apply practical techniques to avoid erroneous inconclusive conclusions
Instructor Photo
Matthew J. Marvin
CLPE, CFWE

Course Logistics

When:

May 3, 2027 - May 7, 2027

Class Time:

8:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Where:

RSA Forensics Latent Print Academy

1524 MS-19

Meridian, MS 39307

Hours:

40

Tuition:

$1,000.00

Local Contact

RSA Forensics

Matt Marvin, Academy Director

601-626-1100

info@rsaforensics.com

Course Schedule

DurationDay 1Day 2Day 3Day 4Day 5
1 HourReach back Questions and AnswersForgeries PresentationLevel 3 Comparisons IntroductionComparisonsTest
1 HourOrientation Exercise PresentationForgeries ExerciseLevel 3 Comparisons – Incipient RidgesTest Review
1 HourExclusions PresentationFabricationsComparisons
1 HourExclusions Exercise follow the rulesFabrications ExerciseLevel 3 Comparisons - Pores
1 HourLunchLunchLunchLunchLunch
1 HourExclusions Exercise follow the rulesInconclusive Decisions PresentationLevel 3 Comparisons - PoresComparisonsComparisons
1 HourExclusions Exercise the rules don’t applyInconclusive Decisions ExerciseLevel 3 Comparisons – Edges of Ridges
1 HourIncreasing the Difficulty Tracking Through DistortionOne Discrepancy Exercises and Handouts
1 HourIncreasing the Difficulty Comparisons CasesLevel 3 Comparison CombinedClosing and final review

Recommended Reading

  • The Fingerprint Sourcebook, National Institute of Justice, Chapter 9-4.

Helpful Lodging Information

Although we cannot endorse any particular hotel property, we have confirmed that the following lodging options are within a reasonable commuting distance to the training site.

Drury Inn & Suites Meridian

112 US-11

Meridian MS 39301